Warning: spoilers for “The Defenders” and some of the other Netflix shows will follow. Read at your own risk.
So it’s finally here…the event we’ve been waiting for. “The Defenders” brings all four of the Netflix superheroes together so they can kick some butt. And maybe throw bad guys through a building or two (I really gotta stop making that joke). But the real question is, was it worth it? Is “The Defenders” everything we hoped for? Is it everything we wanted…nay…deserved?!
Well…yes and no.
But before we get into the nitty-gritty of the show, I wanted to point out a couple small details I appreciated. After “Iron Fist” and its bland title sequence, I was glad to see they brought back the nuance for “The Defenders”. During the title sequence, we see each of the four characters forms overlaid over aerial maps of New York. Now, I can’t be certain considering I know basically nothing about New York, but I believe that each character is overlaid over the particular part of the city where they live and operate.
So Daredevil would have a part of Hell’s Kitchen while Luke Cage would be laid over Harlem. But the detail in the title sequence goes beyond that even. I didn’t really pick up on this until near the end of the first episode, but each character has a particular color associated with them, a color that you can see during the title sequence itself. During the show, scenes that particular character dominates are color corrected to have an abundance of that character’s color.
Jessica Jones has a deep blue, while Danny Rand is green. This little detail takes to the sidelines once the characters finally start to meet up with each other, but it’s still a cool aspect of the show. It’s not essential, but it’s these little things that fans love.
But anyway, on to the main event. Like I said before, the answer to the question “was it worth the wait” is a little bit of a mixed bag. The breakdown (at least for me) seemed to go like this: the first half of “The Defenders” is great while the second half gets a little sloppy. I thoroughly enjoyed the first four episodes, watching as each of the heroes runs into their own problem to solve. It was nice checking back in with these characters and seeing what they had been up to, although the first episode does spend more time on Luke Cage than anyone else. Which makes sense, considering he was being carted off to jail at the end of the first season of his show, so they have to deal with that to get him back into place.
It was fun watching each of these characters do the thing they do best, with a slow buildup towards the inevitable meeting of the heroes. The problem is that after these four characters meet and begrudgingly agree to work together, the show seems to lose a bit of momentum, as the next few episodes mostly feature the characters sitting around and debating their next move before the final showdown begins.
And it’s at this point that you realize just how weak Danny Rand is as a character when compared to the other three.
Now, to give some credit to the writers, they at least tried to give Danny a more interesting arc than just “I’m the Iron Fist…it is my destiny to destroy The Hand…blah blah blah”. In the first episode, Danny has a nightmare about the apparent massacre of the people of K’un-Lun, showing that he feels guilty over leaving them. The problem is that, after the first episode, this is never mentioned or referenced again. In fact, Danny is played as more of a laughingstock than anything else, especially in the second half of the season. Any time someone mentions that he’s the Iron Fist, everyone else in the room seems to have the same reaction of “the hell are you talking about?” A good example of this would be when Murdock tells his friend Foggy that Danny’s the Iron Fist and Foggy remarks “I’m not even going to pretend I know what that means.”
I didn’t mind this approach at first, but the more I thought about it the more it bothered me. You see, instead of trying to fix the flaws in Danny’s character they turned him into a literal joke. The other characters pretty much just make fun of everything he says. They took the lazy route and played Danny up for laughs instead of trying to make him feel deserving of a place on the team. This is made all the more insulting once you realize that Danny is integral to the entire plot of the show. The Hand needs him to complete their master plan. Without him, their whole scheme falls apart. In this sense, Danny feels less like a character and more like a maguffin, existing only to move the plot forward toward the inevitable battle against The Hand.
And speaking of The Hand, their big leader in this show is revealed to be a woman named Alexandra, played by none other than Sigourney Weaver. Initially, I was excited to see her in this show, because Sigourney Weaver is a total badass. Remember “Alien”? Remember “Aliens”? Yeah…total badass right? But here she’s given very little to do aside from look imposing and make not so subtle references to the fact that she’s older than she appears, like when she calls Istanbul Constantinople. She also has some very cringe worthy dialogue later on, even breaking out the “we’re the same, you and I” speech at one point.
She is given a motivation though. At the beginning of the show we are shown that she’s dying…all of her organs are systematically shutting down one by one. This encourages her to push The Hand’s plan into fast-forward mode, despite the objections. Because as it turns out, The Hand’s immortality revolves around a mysterious substance that they have run out of. This bit didn’t make much sense to me, considering that we’ve seen people resurrect in the other shows without the help of this substance. So why now do they suddenly need more of it? Seems to me like another maguffin to get the plot where it needs to go. Because, as it turns out, they used the last of this substance on Elektra.
Speaking of Elektra, what the hell is her motivation here anyways? After her death at the end of the second season of “Daredevil”, Elektra is brought back to life by The Hand. But her memory is erased so she can be turned into The Hand’s ultimate weapon. Through some more not so subtle moments, we realize that this conditioning isn’t going to last forever, and that Elektra is starting to remember who she was. But the thing is, once she remembers who she is, she still serves as an antagonist for no apparent reason. If she remembers who she is, then why the hell would she be fighting against the man she supposedly loves? It makes no sense.
And what’s so important about her being the “Black Sky” anyways? Everyone goes on and on about it, but it’s never clearly explained what it actually means.
However, despite the flaws, “The Defenders” is a fun time. The best scene is definitely the fight at the end of the third episode, where all four of the heroes come together for the first time and battle a bunch of The Hand’s henchmen. But after that, the show starts going downhill. It never gets to the point of being unwatchable, but through some strange plot choices and sloppy pacing, the second half definitely isn’t as strong. I especially didn’t like the shenanigans they tried to pull in the last episode. I won’t say much out of fear of spoiling it for those who haven’t watched it, but I will say this: they try to make you think that one thing happened, only to turn it around in the last thirty seconds of the show and be all like “ha we tricked you” even though most people will probably see it coming from a mile away.
At the very least, there isn’t any pointless filler. Each episode moves things along the main plot. So while it might not be everything we hoped for, it’s still well worth a watch, especially if you’ve gotten invested in the characters.
And now, if you’ll indulge me, I’m going to go on a more personal rant…
I really wish The Hand hadn’t been the villains for “The Defenders”. It takes things to such a cheesy, comic book level that it’s hard to take seriously sometimes. It’s a group of frickin’ immortal ninjas for crying out loud! Part of the reason I really enjoyed these Netflix shows at first was because of how different they felt from the standard superhero fare. The first season of “Daredevil” hardly feels like a superhero show at all. It plays like a gritty crime drama but with a superhero twist. But as time went on The Hand became more and more apparent as Marvel rushed things out the door in order to get them into place for “The Defenders”.
I would have liked to see the four heroes fight against a crime syndicate for their first outing together. Now I know someone is going to say it…”but…The Hand is a crime syndicate”. It is, but it’s still a crime syndicate of immortal ninjas. I would have wanted to see them face off against regular criminals, not a bunch of silly mystical types who, despite all the hype over being super secretive, take some really obvious actions.
A whole army of ninjas clad in black rappelling up the side of a hospital? Sure seems stealthy to me!
I think it would have been more interesting if, for example, Wilson Fisk had been exposed but not captured at the end of “Daredevil” season one. He could then escape to run things from the shadows and give the heroes a threat to deal with when they finally came together. And with the addition of Danny Rand, they could have started teasing the existence of a mysterious organization known as The Hand. Then, after the four heroes came together and defeated Fisk once and for all, The Hand could step out of the shadows and reveal that they were manipulating Fisk the entire time. That would then give The Defenders another threat looming over them as they go about their own business. Because, with The Hand gone, there’s no bigger threat anymore, not to mention that Danny Rand’s character has no purpose anymore, since his whole thing revolved around The Hand’s defeat. I can’t really see their next big villains standing up to a bunch of supernatural martial artists.
And with that, I’m off. Blog writer AWAAAAAY!
Thanks for reading. Check back next Wednesday for another post, and as always, have a wonderful week.