Here in the United States, we consider ourselves a capitalist society. And what that means in the long run is that money makes the world go round. In some ways, this can be a good thing. It breeds competition, and the beauty of the human spirit is that competition can bring out the best in us. To put it another way, we often do our best work under pressure. I know that’s true. I once wrote a seven-page paper in high school the night before it was due, and I received an A on it. Not only that, but the teacher wanted to use it as an example for future classes.
Let’s just say I casually left out the part about writing it the night before…
But not everything is gumdrops and rainbows. When it comes to any system, there are pros and cons. While competition can inspire creativity, it can also breed a certain sort of staleness in the market. Look at video games and movies, and you’ll often find trends. A while back, it seemed like Hollywood was obsessed with making alien invasion movies. Then it was dark re-imaginings of classic fairy tales. And now it’s superheroes. We can’t seem to go more than a couple of months without a new superhero movie hitting the market. It’s not that superhero movies are a bad thing. I happen to enjoy a few of them (although I am getting tired of them these days, especially after the disappointing Avengers: Age of Ultron). But with success comes imitation, and that’s where my problem with the whole thing lies.
With the way our economy is doing right now, and people’s reluctance to spend a lot of money, we tend to see the same types of movies making all the money. People like to see what they know they will enjoy. It’s hard for them to justify going to watch a movie that’s outside their normal comfort zone or that they haven’t heard great praise about. This is part of the reason why I think Hollywood has fallen into a trend of remaking old movies or adapting stories from books or other sources. If the old movie or book has a big enough audience, then they can bank on people at least going to see it out of curiosity.
The problem is that this mode of thinking stifles creativity, in that we hardly ever see original plots in movies (by which I mean that we see a plot written exclusively to be a movie, not adapted form another source). Sure, you could consider Star Wars: The Force Awakens to be an original movie. But there are two problems with that assertion. One, The Force Awakens is already part of a large, established franchise that has been around for decades. And two (possible minor spoilers follow), the movie is steeped in nostalgia. It hits a lot of the same story beats as A New Hope, meaning that while it features a new story and new characters, a lot of the plot points feel readily familiar.
You can observe the same phenomena in the video game world, although in a different form. Video games don’t tend to adapt stories from other sources. Instead, they can suffer from an overflow of sequels. A good example of this is the Call of Duty franchise, which has been around for a long time and has spawned over two dozen different games. The general complaint around the series is that most of the games feel the same. But at the same time, there must be an incentive for them to be so similar. At the end of the day, they want to turn a profit. So many franchises get caught in this delicate balance between changing enough of the game to justify a sequel in the mind of gamers, but also leaving enough of its core intact so that people feel at home with it. This is something franchises like Grand Theft Auto have gotten so good at. They change with the times, getting more and more advanced in look and feel, but they are loaded with nostalgia, giving the hardcore fans little hints and nods at the older games in the series.
You see this in movie sequels as well. They have to up the ante with each successive movie, making things bigger (like the explosions…always bigger explosions), but also keeping the core feel of their fictional universe intact. This line of thinking can end up creating a feedback loop where the same few stories get told over and over again.
But sometimes this drive of competition and money can lead to good ideas in the long run. Let’s again look to the video game world, specifically at Bethesda Game Studios. Bethesda, most known for their Elder Scrolls series of video games, isn’t just a game development company. They are a publisher as well, and one of the better ones to work for from what I’ve heard. The developers of the game Dishonored were basically told by Bethesda to take all the time they needed to make the game as good as they desired. Bethesda wasn’t on a time crunch. They didn’t need money immediately. The Elder Scrolls games sell like crazy every time they come out. They’re one of the most trusted game developers in the market, so they can allow themselves to take chances on nontraditional ideas or unproven intellectual properties.
The same thing is true of books. Unlike movies and games, books aren’t constantly driven by this idea of success and money, although it still plays a role. Take Stephen King for example. He may be known for his horror stories, but King has also written a fantasy series known as the Dark Tower series, which is a blend of different genres including western, dark fantasy, science fantasy, and horror (of course). When you have a stable reputation and income, you can feel free to experiment and try new things. But this experimental mindset is still tempered by the idea of competition, in that you want to make your creation as good as possible so that people will enjoy it.
In the long run, money might be more of a detriment to creativity than anything, but like all things in the world it isn’t a simple black and white situation. People won’t be inclined to try making something new when they can make something they know works. But at the same time, trying new things can lead to unexpected success.
After all, trends have to start somewhere.
Well that’s all I have for this time. Tune in next Wednesday for a new post, and as always, have a wonderful week!
This blog just hit one hundred posts! It’s an incredible milestone for me, one that I wish I had prepared for a little better. I honestly didn’t realize I had hit it until I started writing this post. It amazes me that I’ve come this far. And I haven’t missed a single week since I began this blog. Every week, on Wednesday, I have made a post. They might not have all been good (I am particularly disappointed with my story analysis posts…I never did manage to shape those into something I was satisfied with), but consistency is one of the greatest habits you can get into. You will only get better at something as long as you keep doing it.
So thank you all for following me this far and for reading my weekly ramblings.
Once again, have a wonderful week! See you next Wednesday.